top of page

Election season blues

Nov 2
6 min read

Hang tight, Friends. The amoral onslaught of election season has almost passed. Gone, if only for a moment, will be the ugly, unwanted invasions of candidate messaging, and restored will be our focus on that over which we truly have a more tangible influence on the outcome. But just as surely as election season will return in the next cycle, it is vital to prevent that bombardment of political advertising from leading us astray from our plans and our purpose. Most of that messaging warns that our economic survival depends entirely on the outcome of a single Tuesday in November, and it’s simply not true.


When market volatility picks up during late summer and autumn of an election year, it is easy to assume Wall Street is having the exact same emotional reaction. It feels like the market is panicking about the candidates, the ideological divide, or the political direction of the country.



In reality, the market does not possess a political affiliation. It does not lose sleep over partisan platforms, campaign rallies, or political bumper stickers. What the market despises above all else is something far simpler: a question mark.


Understanding the difference between political drama and market mechanics is the single most valuable perspective an investor can have right now. It is the dividing line between reacting with anxiety and maintaining clear-eyed financial discipline.


The Anatomy of the Pre-Election Discount

In business, ambiguity is expensive. Whether you are running a multinational corporation, managing a commercial real estate portfolio, or leading a growing company here in Central Texas, planning for the next three to five years requires having a predictable set of parameters. You want to know what corporate tax rates will look like, how regulatory agencies will approach your industry, what trade agreements will remain intact, and who will shape energy and labor policy.


In the months leading up to a major election—especially as fiercely contested as this midterm cycle has been—those parameters become hazy.


When institutional money managers, sovereign wealth funds, and corporate boards encounter a cloudy forecast, they tap the brakes. Companies delay capital expenditures, postpone hiring sprees, and wait on major acquisitions until the outcome is decided. Portfolio managers purchase downside insurance and elevate cash reserves.


This collective hesitation acts like a temporary drag on asset prices—an "uncertainty tax." The market discounts stock valuations not because the future is necessarily bleak, but because the near-term rules of engagement are unconfirmed.


The moment the votes are tallied, the fog clears. The question mark is replaced with a period. Even if the electoral outcome is not the exact scenario that business leaders or individual investors personally preferred, the rules of the road are finally known. Once the framework is set, corporate leaders adjust their operations, institutional capital flows off the sidelines, and the market typically stages what market historians call a post-election relief rally.


What the Historical Data Reveals

While every election cycle feels unique and unprecedented to those living through it, the historical record of election cycles shows remarkably consistent patterns.

According to historical research conducted by Capital Group, spanning every midterm election cycle since 1931, the median return for the S&P 500 during the first nine months of a midterm election year has averaged just 4.7%. By comparison, the index has averaged a 9.5% return over that same nine-month period in non-midterm years. That difference reflects the weight of the uncertainty tax.


However, Capital Group’s historical data shows an equally distinct pattern once that uncertainty resolves: in the 12 months following a midterm election, the S&P 500 has rebounded to produce an average return of 15.4%.


Historical Performance Pattern: The Midterm Cycle

Pre-Election (First 9 Months of Midterm Year):

+4.7% Median Return

Non-Midterm Comparison (First 9 Months):

+9.5% Average Return

Post-Election Rebound (12 Months Following Midterm):

+15.4% Average Return

Source: Capital Group historical analysis (1931–present)


This dynamic is further reinforced by multi-decade data from the Charles Schwab Center for Financial Research. Schwab’s analysis reveals that while the S&P 500 has historically tended to remain flat or choppy in the immediate three months leading into a midterm vote, the index has posted an average gain of 12.4% in the six to 12 months following the election. Notably, across modern midterm cycles, the forward 12-month returns following election day have historically delivered positive performance in virtually every single cycle.


Additional data from J.P. Morgan Asset Management tracking quarterly seasonality indicates that the fourth quarter of midterm election years has historically averaged a 6.6% gain, representing the strongest quarter of the entire four-year presidential cycle.

The primary engine of market performance over multi-year horizons is not the composition of Congress or which party occupies the governor's mansion. It is corporate earnings, productivity gains, interest rate policy, and the compounding engine of American free enterprise.


To illustrate this reality, J.P. Morgan examined the annualized returns of the S&P 500 across divergent political leadership. Under the administration of Barack Obama, the S&P 500 generated an annualized return of 16.3%. Under the administration of Donald Trump, the S&P 500 produced an annualized return of 16.0%. Two completely opposing philosophies, two entirely different governing styles, yet virtually identical double-digit annual performance for disciplined investors who stayed the course. Read that last part again.


The Cost of Partisan Portfolio Decisions

The real financial danger during an election season rarely comes from who wins the race; it comes from what investors do to their own portfolios while trying to guess what happens next.


When an investor feels passionately about political philosophy, it is extraordinarily easy to confuse personal political conviction with financial risk. We hear it every cycle: *"If that party wins, the economy is finished, and I want to sit in cash until things calm down."*


That emotional reaction creates a trap. Moving to the sidelines requires making two separate, high-stakes decisions correctly: picking the exact day to step out of the market, and picking the exact day to step back in.


Because post-election relief rallies frequently ignite immediately after the election results solidify—often within days or weeks of the vote—investors who liquidate their holdings to wait for "calmer waters" almost always miss the sharpest upside moves. In investing, missing just a handful of the market's strongest trading days over a decade can significantly impair long-term compounding.


Anchored by Design, Not by Politics

When we sit down to build and review your balance sheet in RightCapital, we intentionally design your plan so you never have to worry about who is running Washington or Austin.


A sound financial plan does not require ideal government policy to succeed. We purposefully assume that there will be periods of contentious politics, tax reform debates, legislative gridlock, and regulatory swings. We stress-test your cash flow, your liquid reserves, and your retirement distribution schedules against actual market history, which includes depressions, world wars, inflationary shocks, and contested elections.


If you are currently in your peak career years saving aggressively, seasonal election pullbacks are simply opportunities where your monthly contributions purchase top-tier companies at a temporary discount. If you are retired and living off structured portfolio distributions and real estate cash flows, your near-term income is already insulated in stable reserves, meaning short-term equity swings do not dictate your daily standard of living.


Vote your values with passion on Election Day, and engage in the civic process as you see fit. But when it comes to your life’s savings, treat the noise on the airwaves for what it is: temporary turbulence that creates long-term opportunity for the patient and disciplined.


If the constant stream of campaign ads or headlines ever starts to feel like a distraction, feel free to open up your RightCapital portal and review your lifetime plan, or let Lucy know and we will get lunch on the calendar here in New Braunfels to talk it through. You have built a resilient financial house, and our team is right here keeping watch so you can focus on enjoying the life you’ve built.


Run a Stress Test

RightCapital carries a wonderful Stress Test tool that I encourage you to explore. You will find it on the submenu under the Retirement tab next to Analysis. Once inside, you can tinker with your own hypothetical scenarios, to range from items with no political correlations at all (living longer than planned) to items with heavy political correlations (reductions in social security). Use it to explore the consequences of various possibilities. You will likely be surprised by what has substantial influence on the meter and what does not. Feel free to reach out to me with any questions or concerns you find within.


Where Political Ad Dollars Are Going

Credit: Visual Capitalist

 
 
 

Comments


Force Acres, LLC, is a registered investment advisor offering advisory services in the State of Texas and in other jurisdictions where exempted. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. The information on this site for informational purposes only and should not be considered a solicitation to buy, an offer to sell, or a recommendation of any security or advisory service in any jurisdiction where such solicitation, offer, or recommendation would be unlawful or unauthorized. The information provided should not be relied upon as the sole factor in an investment making decision. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.

© 2026 by Force Acres, LLC

bottom of page